Ontario Car Insurance Rates 2026

Compare auto insurance across 62 Ontario cities. Provincial average: CA$161/month (CA$1,927/year). Insurance system: private. Regulator: FSRA.

CA$161/mo
Provincial Average
CA$1,476
Lowest City (Hanover)
CA$3,259
Highest City (annual)
62
Cities Covered
Get Free ON Quotes

About Ontario Auto Insurance

Ontario operates a private insurance system regulated by FSRA. All drivers must carry minimum Third-Party Liability of CA$200,000. The mandatory coverage package includes Statutory Accident Benefits (SABs), Direct Compensation-Property Damage (DCPD), and Uninsured Automobile Coverage.

Ontario's most significant auto insurance reform in two decades takes effect July 1, 2026: the new Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule allows drivers to select benefit levels a-la-carte rather than purchasing the standard package. For high-premium drivers this can reduce premiums by 5–15%, but inadequate benefit selection creates coverage gaps. Work with a licensed Ontario broker to model the correct selection for your situation before the next renewal.

Ontario's 2026 SABS a-la-carte reform (effective July 1, 2026) allows drivers to customize their accident benefit coverage levels. Consult a licensed broker before opting down.

Ontario City Car Insurance Rates — 62 Cities Compared

Ajax

CA$172/mo
Save up to CA$371/yr
Moderate Risk · Intact

Aurora

CA$167/mo
Save up to CA$360/yr
Moderate Risk · CAA

Barrie

CA$181/mo
Save up to CA$391/yr
Moderate-High Risk · Intact

Belleville

CA$142/mo
Save up to CA$306/yr
Low Risk · Co-operators

Brantford

CA$158/mo
Save up to CA$342/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Economical

Brockville

CA$137/mo
Save up to CA$295/yr
Low Risk · CAA

Burlington

CA$176/mo
Save up to CA$380/yr
Moderate Risk · Aviva

Cambridge

CA$168/mo
Save up to CA$363/yr
Moderate Risk · Economical

Cobourg

CA$147/mo
Save up to CA$317/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Co-operators

Collingwood

CA$135/mo
Save up to CA$292/yr
Low Risk · Intact

Cornwall

CA$135/mo
Save up to CA$292/yr
Low Risk · Intact

Dryden

CA$133/mo
Save up to CA$287/yr
Low Risk · Co-operators

Elliot Lake

CA$128/mo
Save up to CA$276/yr
Low Risk · Co-operators

Fort Erie

CA$145/mo
Save up to CA$313/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Aviva

Goderich

CA$133/mo
Save up to CA$287/yr
Low Risk · Economical

Guelph

CA$165/mo
Save up to CA$356/yr
Moderate Risk · Co-operators

Hamilton

CA$171/mo
Save up to CA$369/yr
Moderate Risk · Intact

Hanover

CA$123/mo
Save up to CA$266/yr
Low Risk · Economical

Kawartha Lakes

CA$148/mo
Save up to CA$320/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Co-operators

Kenora

CA$130/mo
Save up to CA$281/yr
Low Risk · Co-operators

Kingston

CA$152/mo
Save up to CA$328/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · CAA

Kirkland Lake

CA$125/mo
Save up to CA$270/yr
Low Risk · Economical

Kitchener

CA$170/mo
Save up to CA$367/yr
Moderate Risk · Economical

London

CA$174/mo
Save up to CA$376/yr
Moderate Risk · Intact

Markham

CA$182/mo
Save up to CA$393/yr
High Risk · Aviva

Midland

CA$133/mo
Save up to CA$287/yr
Low Risk · Co-operators

Milton

CA$170/mo
Save up to CA$367/yr
Moderate Risk · Aviva

Mississauga

CA$272/mo
Save up to CA$587/yr
High Risk · Intact

Newmarket

CA$168/mo
Save up to CA$363/yr
Moderate Risk · CAA

Niagara Falls

CA$164/mo
Save up to CA$354/yr
Moderate Risk · Aviva

North Bay

CA$141/mo
Save up to CA$305/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Co-operators

North York

CA$205/mo
Save up to CA$443/yr
High Risk · Aviva

Oakville

CA$187/mo
Save up to CA$403/yr
Moderate-High Risk · Aviva

Orangeville

CA$162/mo
Save up to CA$350/yr
Moderate Risk · Aviva

Orillia

CA$140/mo
Save up to CA$302/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Co-operators

Oshawa

CA$175/mo
Save up to CA$378/yr
Moderate Risk · Intact

Ottawa

CA$128/mo
Save up to CA$276/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · CAA

Owen Sound

CA$132/mo
Save up to CA$285/yr
Low Risk · Economical

Parry Sound

CA$132/mo
Save up to CA$285/yr
Low Risk · Co-operators

Pembroke

CA$132/mo
Save up to CA$285/yr
Low Risk · Intact

Peterborough

CA$155/mo
Save up to CA$335/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Co-operators

Pickering

CA$174/mo
Save up to CA$376/yr
Moderate Risk · Intact

Port Colborne

CA$142/mo
Save up to CA$306/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Aviva

Renfrew

CA$125/mo
Save up to CA$270/yr
Low Risk · CAA

Richmond Hill

CA$175/mo
Save up to CA$378/yr
High Risk · Aviva

Sarnia

CA$155/mo
Save up to CA$335/yr
Moderate Risk · Intact

Sault Ste. Marie

CA$138/mo
Save up to CA$297/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Co-operators

Scarborough

CA$210/mo
Save up to CA$454/yr
High Risk · Intact

Simcoe

CA$147/mo
Save up to CA$317/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · CAA

Smiths Falls

CA$130/mo
Save up to CA$281/yr
Low Risk · Co-operators

St. Catharines

CA$165/mo
Save up to CA$356/yr
Moderate Risk · Intact

Stratford

CA$146/mo
Save up to CA$315/yr
Low Risk · Economical

Sudbury

CA$145/mo
Save up to CA$313/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Intact

Thunder Bay

CA$143/mo
Save up to CA$309/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Co-operators

Tillsonburg

CA$140/mo
Save up to CA$302/yr
Low Risk · Co-operators

Timmins

CA$132/mo
Save up to CA$284/yr
Low Risk · Economical

Vaughan

CA$178/mo
Save up to CA$385/yr
High Risk · Aviva

Waterloo

CA$160/mo
Save up to CA$346/yr
Moderate Risk · Economical

Welland

CA$152/mo
Save up to CA$328/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Co-operators

Whitby

CA$168/mo
Save up to CA$364/yr
Moderate Risk · Intact

Windsor

CA$160/mo
Save up to CA$346/yr
Moderate Risk · Intact

Woodstock

CA$150/mo
Save up to CA$324/yr
Low-Moderate Risk · Economical

Provincial Coverage Requirements

CoverageDescription
Third-Party LiabilityMinimum CA$200,000 required; pays compensation to others for injury or property damage
Statutory Accident Benefits (SABs)Pays your medical, rehabilitation, income replacement, and caregiver benefits regardless of fault
Direct Compensation-Property Damage (DCPD)Covers damage to your vehicle when another insured driver is at fault
Uninsured Automobile CoverageProtects you if you are hit by an uninsured or unidentified driver

PROTECT74