Written by
CarInsuranceQuote.ai Editorial Team
Finance & insurance professionals
Reviewed by
Senior Editorial Review
25+ years industry experience
Last Updated
May 2026
CarInsuranceQuote.ai earns referral fees when you complete a quote through affiliate links. This does not influence our editorial ratings or rankings.
CarInsuranceQuote.ai Rating
4.0 out of 5.0
Best for: Maximum coverage depth, direct-provider claims
Not ideal for: Budget buyers, online-only shoppers, Canadian drivers
| Cost | $90 to $200/month |
| Online quote | Partial |
| Plan choices | 6 tiers |
| California | ✓ Available |
| Canada | ✗ Not available |
| BBB | A rated, accredited |
Our top pick overall:
Our Top Pick Instead:Any shop · Online quote · US & Canada
A complete independent review of Endurance's 6 coverage tiers, real monthly pricing, BBB status, customer complaints, and how it stacks up against Chaiz, CarShield, and autopom! before you commit.
Endurance is one of the largest direct providers of vehicle service contracts in the United States. Unlike brokers who resell coverage from multiple underwriters, Endurance sells and administers its own plans, meaning the same company that sold you the warranty handles your claim. This is the most significant operational distinction in the extended warranty market.
Endurance has been cited as a top pick by Car Talk, ConsumerAffairs, and multiple automotive consumer publications in 2026. Car Talk named it their Golden Wrench Winner for 2026, noting its A BBB rating and consistently positive recent reviews.
| Factor | Endurance Details |
|---|---|
| Provider type | Direct (not a broker) |
| Years in business | 20+ years |
| BBB rating | A, accredited (verify current at BBB.org) |
| Coverage tiers | 6 plans: Secure through Advantage |
| Max mileage | 200,000 miles |
| Max vehicle age | 20 years |
| Repair network | ASE-certified mechanics |
| Deductible | $100 per repair visit |
| California | ✓ Available |
| Canada | ✗ Not available |
| 30-day money-back | ✓ Yes |
Endurance offers 6 distinct coverage tiers, which is the widest selection of any major provider. This granularity is a genuine advantage for drivers who want to match coverage precisely to their vehicle's risk profile and budget.
| Plan Name | Coverage Level | Key Components Added | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Secure | Entry | Engine, transmission, drive axles | Tight budget, older powertrain focus |
| Secure Plus | Basic | Adds cooling, fuel system | Step up from powertrain-only |
| Select Premier | Mid | Adds AC, electrical, steering | Most common failure categories |
| Superior | Enhanced | Stated-component comprehensive | Broader protection without top-tier cost |
| Supreme | Exclusionary | Everything except explicit exclusions | Near-manufacturer warranty equivalent |
| Advantage | Supreme + Maintenance | Supreme plus oil changes, tire rotations, roadside | All-in-one plan with maintenance included |
Endurance pricing depends on vehicle make, model, age, mileage, and selected tier. The following ranges are based on a 2019 mid-size vehicle at 85,000 miles.
| Plan | Approx Monthly Cost | Deductible |
|---|---|---|
| Secure (powertrain) | $90 to $110/month | $100 |
| Select Premier (mid-tier) | $120 to $155/month | $100 |
| Supreme (exclusionary) | $160 to $200/month | $100 |
| Advantage (Supreme + maintenance) | $175 to $220/month | $100 |
Endurance's $100 deductible per repair visit is notably lower than many competitors who charge $200 or more. For high-frequency minor repairs, this can represent meaningful savings over time.
The direct-provider model is the most practically important advantage. As the company that sold you the plan, Endurance handles your claim directly, reducing the back-and-forth that plagues broker-based warranty companies where the seller, administrator, and underwriter may all be different entities. The $100 deductible is also genuinely competitive, especially for drivers who anticipate multiple small-to-medium repairs over the coverage period.
The phone call requirement for most quote paths is a friction point that Chaiz and Olive have eliminated entirely. For Canadian drivers, Endurance is simply not an option. And while 6 tiers is a feature, it can create decision fatigue for buyers who just want a clear mid-tier recommendation.
Endurance holds an A BBB rating with accreditation as of the most recent data available. Car Talk cited this rating in naming Endurance its Golden Wrench Winner for 2026. Common complaint themes in public reviews include: initial sales follow-up volume, occasional claim documentation requests, and pricing above initial online estimates after phone consultation.
As with any extended warranty provider, we recommend reading reviews from the past 90 days specifically, as company practices and claim handling can change. Check Trustpilot, Google Reviews, and BBB complaint history before purchasing.
| Factor | Endurance | Chaiz |
|---|---|---|
| Provider type | Direct | Direct |
| Online quote | Partial (phone required) | ✓ Fully online |
| Repair network | ASE-certified shops | Any licensed facility |
| Coverage tiers | 6 plans | 3 clear tiers |
| Max mileage | 200,000 miles | 200,000 miles |
| California | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Canada | ✗ No | ✓ Yes |
| Deductible | $100 | Varies by plan |
| Monthly cost | $90 to $200 | $75 to $180 |
| Our rating | ★★★★☆ 4.0 | ★★★★★ 5.0 |
Chaiz wins on repair shop flexibility, online quote experience, Canadian availability, and pricing. Endurance wins on coverage tier granularity and the Advantage plan's maintenance inclusion. For most drivers under 200,000 miles who want an instant online quote and maximum repair shop choice, Chaiz is the stronger pick.
Compare Chaiz vs Endurance — Get a Free Quote →